Put Something in Their Hands
Physical objects travel into homes, stay on shelves, and outlast every change to the feed. Treat them as a channel with its own economics.
Somewhere, a stranger still keeps the thing you mailed them years ago. No feed can take that back.
You've seen it in comments and DMs. A photo of your zine on someone's nightstand, a print framed in a dorm room, a sticker on a laptop at an airport gate. Nobody asked. They kept it because it came from you and it felt like proof they were there early.
A post lives for a day or two in a feed you don't control, while a good object can stay in someone's home for years. It sits in their line of sight every morning, gets picked up by visitors, and starts conversations you'll never hear about. Per dollar of attention, a well-made physical thing is one of the most durable touchpoints a creator can offer.
It also produces something digital channels can't, which is a mailing address attached to a person who paid or opted in to receive something real. That list is small, and it's worth more than a much larger follower count, because those people have already crossed from watching your work to owning a piece of it.
The trap is treating objects as merch drops, where the goal is margin and volume. The better frame of mind is a small number of well-made things, sent on purpose. A printed annual of your best work, a numbered run of something useful, or a letter at year's end to the people who've been around longest.
I'd start with one object a year and a list of a few hundred people. Price it close to cost, or give it to your longest-standing members, and pay attention to the weeks after it arrives. People post it, reply to emails they'd been ignoring, and turn up at the next live event with it in their hands.
You already have the part that's hard to manufacture, which is people who care enough to want a piece of the work. It doesn't need its own budget line at first, only a few hundred addresses, a printer or small manufacturer you trust, and one afternoon a year deciding what's worth putting in the mail. Giving them something they can hold is a small gesture, and it tends to be the one they remember.